What is the best way to thicken rice pudding? A Simple Guide to Thickening Rice Pudding

Rate this post

Rice pudding is a dish cooked with rice, milk, and additional ingredients such as raisins, sugar, or honey in a variety of variations.

In addition, some fruit may be added to the dish. It is often offered as a dessert at cafés.

It may also be produced at home, however stirring is normally required to prevent lumps from developing.

Rice pudding is a simple treat, and this article will walk you through the process of creating it.

In addition to thickening, we discuss several frequent errors made by amateurs while creating rice pudding.

How to Make Rice Pudding?

How to Thicken Rice Pudding? Easy Guide to Thicken Rice Pudding

Rice pudding is a quick and easy treat. Rice is cooked in milk with sugar, vanilla, or additional flavorings such as cinnamon or lemon peel.

Raisins may also be added to the rice pudding. Cooking rice in milk causes it to break down and thicken.

Preparing risotto or Carnaroli Risotto with Saffron is similar.

Both preparations are almost identical in method, and both lend themselves nicely to experimentation.

Try adding lemon peel or cinnamon to your rice pudding recipe, for example. The dish provided here is straightforward, with no added flavorings.

However, for extra taste, you may add some lemon peel or vanilla essence. It’s also flavored with nutmeg, which makes it even more fascinating and unique to consume.

The combination of two varieties of rice adds to the dish’s appeal. The following are the steps for creating rice pudding:

  • Begin by combining the milk, rice, sugar, and nutmeg. While doing so, constantly stirring the liquid to ensure that no lumps develop. To make it more appealing, add some butter to the preparation.
  • When the rice mixture is smooth, transfer it to a saucepan with boiling water. To prevent lumps, keep stirring the mixture constantly.
  • Simmer for 35-40 minutes or longer, stirring often, over low heat. The rice will dissolve and thicken the mixture. Check for consistency on a regular basis. Remove from the heat and set aside to cool before serving with a sprinkling of nutmeg.
  • As previously said, you may flavor the mixture with a few drops of lemon or vanilla essence. To make it more creamy and thick, replace half of the milk with cream.

Why Your Rice Pudding is Runny & Watery?

How to Thicken Rice Pudding? Easy Guide to Thicken Rice Pudding

It is essential not to stop stirring the rice pudding to get a smooth and creamy consistency and prevent lumps.

This may be difficult for beginners since they often overcook or leave the mixture unattended for too long.

However, you must keep stirring until all of the milk has been absorbed by the rice.

When the mixture has a creamy and smooth consistency, the pudding is nearly done.

If there are lumps in the mixture after adding extra milk, your rice pudding will turn watery.

Unless thoroughly cooked beforehand, rice tends to develop lumps readily. You may prevent this by stirring constantly when adding milk.

Another reason rice pudding is watery is the amount of milk used.

The milk-to-rice ratio should be 1 part rice to 2 parts milk.

If there is insufficient rice in the combination, it will turn watery since there are no grounds to absorb more milk.

However, adding too much rice might result in lumps, making the pudding watery.

Other Mistakes When Making Rice Pudding?

There are various more blunders that amateurs who attempt to create rice pudding make.

Boiling the milk first, for example, makes it more difficult to get a smooth consistency in your rice pudding.

Because the rice is cooked in boiling milk, there will be lumps and little likelihood of getting rid of them.

When making rice pudding, start with cold milk instead.

Another common blunder is using just one part milk and more than three parts rice.

Milk takes longer than rice to break down correctly, which may account for the watery or runny quality of your pudding.

If you add too much salt, the rice will become hard. The right quantity of salt is just enough to make the rice taste good.

If you want a different taste in your pudding, use vanilla extract for the salt.

Allow the components to cool before keeping them in the refrigerator after thoroughly mixing them.

It should be left overnight to let the flavors to mix well before storing for up to 3 days.

When cooking a creamy and tasty pudding, the most essential thing to remember is the milk-to-rice ratio.

The consistency of your pudding will be totally determined by the amount of milk used, so don’t hurry while making it.

How to Thicken Rice Pudding?

Rice pudding may be thickened by cooking it for a longer period of time than normal.

You should also whisk the mixture often to prevent lumps that develop after the rice absorbs all of the milk.

Using more rice will make the pudding tenderer and smoother, while adding more milk will make it runny.

Here are a few different ways to thicken rice pudding.

1 Use Cornstarch

Cornstarch is the finest technique to thicken rice pudding. All you have to do is combine 3 tablespoons cornstarch with a little milk and add it at the end of the rice pudding making process.

The remainder of the mixture will quickly thicken, and you may enjoy this creamy delicacy.

2 Use Mashed Bananas

Adding mashed or sliced bananas to rice pudding is another technique to thicken it.

While preparing the pudding, add 1-2 chunks of banana for this.

This may be done at the end, just before serving, and will thicken the texture of your rice pudding. If you dislike the taste of cornstarch, this is a suitable substitute.

3 Add More Rice

If you want to thicken the rice pudding even more, add additional rice. This will quickly make it incredibly creamy and yummy.

If you don’t have any cornstarch or bananas on hand, use this as a last option to thicken rice pudding.

4 Use Less Milk

Using less milk in your rice pudding will thicken it and give it a gritty texture rather than creamy and smooth.

Because there isn’t enough milk for the rice to absorb, it may taste watery.

5 Add Eggs

Adding a few eggs to your rice pudding while it’s cooking can thicken it.

However, you must exercise caution since this may influence the consistency of your pudding.

Some folks may dislike the texture and flavor of the extra long-cooked egg in their dessert.

6 Blend Your Rice Pudding

If you want to remove lumps from your rice pudding, blending it is the finest option. This will need the use of a blender or food processor.

Make careful not to overdo it, since this can cause the pudding to become overly runny or lumpy.

7 Make Rice Pudding in a Slow Cooker

Using your slow cooker to produce creamy and thick rice pudding without adding too many ingredients is the best approach.

It works by slowly heating the mixture over low heat until it reaches the proper consistency.

This is referred to as slow cooking. If you don’t want to add an additional tablespoon of corn starch, you should absolutely use this way.


Rice pudding is a popular comfort dish, particularly among kids who like this sweet dessert.

It makes a fantastic dessert or snack and may be eaten at any time of year.

However, if you are dissatisfied with the quality of your rice pudding, which may be overly runny, you have many solutions.

With this knowledge, you will be able to produce the ultimate creamy, smooth, and scrumptious rice pudding in a matter of minutes.


How do you make rice pudding thicker?

If your rice pudding is too thin, it’s because you didn’t simmer it long enough at the end to thicken the custard. Pour it into a saucepan, boil, then whisk in a little of cornstarch mixed with cold water, a little at a time, until the pudding thickens as required.

Will my rice pudding thicken as it cools?

It will thicken more as it cools, but you may lighten it up with a bit additional milk shortly before serving. There’s no need to run out and get any short grain or medium grain rice. With long grain rice, this Old-Fashioned Rice Pudding comes out well.

How do you thicken runny pudding?

To thicken pudding, use all-purpose flour, potato starch, arrowroot powder, or tapioca starch for the cornstarch. You may thicken banana pudding by adding egg yolks, gelatin, or cornstarch. Cornstarch is an excellent choice since it is less costly and more widely available than other forms of food.

What causes rice pudding to thicken as it cooks?

The response of the starch content of the rice of milk when cooked thickens rice pudding in numerous recipes. Some rice pudding recipes, on the other hand, call for eggs, which make a thicker consistency, and some even ask for cornstarch.

Why isn’t my pudding mixture thickening?

The key approach to thicken pudding without adding extra thickeners is to be mindful of how much you are mixing it up. If you mix it too quickly, it will become too watery. If you mix it too little, the components will not blend properly.

What makes homemade pudding thick?

It is usually cooked with milk or cream, however there are nondairy puddings created using plant-based “milk.” Both pudding and custard may include eggs and milk, however pudding is often thickened with a starch, and custard is thickened by the eggs.

Why is the rice in my rice pudding still hard?

Perhaps you didn’t put enough liquid in the first place. If your rice seems dry, or the texture is still hard or gritty after all of the liquid has been absorbed, add up to 12 cup water and return to a simmer with the cover on.

What temp does pudding thicken?

When cooked over 185 degrees, egg-based puddings and custards may curdle. We remove crème anglaise from the fire when the temperature reaches 175 to 180 degrees Fahrenheit, but while producing the base for ice cream, we raise the temperature to 180 to 185 degrees Fahrenheit for maximum thickness.

Why is my rice pudding mushy?

Mushy or soggy rice is simply overcooked rice that has absorbed an excessive amount of water. Over-absorption of water causes the rice grains to break apart, altering the texture and resulting in a starchy, sticky product.

How do you thicken pudding without cornstarch or flour?

Combine an alternate starch-based thickener, such as arrowroot powder, tapioca powder, or rice starch, with the sugar specified in your pudding recipe. In terms of thickening strength, these alternative starches are similar to cornstarch and twice as strong as wheat flour, so measure accordingly.

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *