How Do You Thicken a Pudding? A Simple Way to Thickening Pudding

Rate this post

Pudding is a smooth, thick dish created with a variety of components such as flour, milk or cream, sugar, and eggs.

Pudding is often served hot with a dipping sauce such as chocolate sauce or a custard topping.

Puddings are frequently blended with other sweets to create an exotic pudding dish, such as a baked banana pudding topped with vanilla ice cream or other fruits.

While puddings are simple to prepare, some may ask why they need to be thickened.

After all, if you’re eating it at home rather than for a big group, there’s no need to obsess about minor details.

In this essay, we will investigate why thickening pudding is important and how it is accomplished.

Pudding Errors You Should Avoid

While creating a pudding, there are two types of faults that you may make.

The first is due to improper cooking practices, while the second is related to a lack of understanding about how components interact with one another.

Undercooking is the most frequent error while creating dessert puddings such as chocolate cake or cream pudding.

To be safe to consume, the puddings must be cooked until they are well cooked.

In other words, cooking a pudding implies thoroughly heating it, which kills any hazardous or toxic microorganisms present.

To do so, you must first determine if the puddings have been thoroughly cooked.

If the pudding retains its form after cooling, it is considered well done.

If your pudding has become mushy and has begun to break apart, it requires longer cooking time.

Overcooking is another typical error that people make.

In this situation, the dessert will be overdone and will not hold its form after cooling.

You may prevent this by checking to see whether your pudding is ready to be removed from the oven before it reaches that stage.

Underbaking occurs as a consequence of the overcooking step, resulting in a rubbery pudding.

People will not want to bite into something that feels like chewing on rubber bands if you offer it as a dessert.

That is why it is critical to check the pudding before it reaches the over-cooked zone, which occurs immediately after being well done.

As you can see, understanding when to remove your puddings from the oven and allowing them to cool enough so that they do not overcook are two critical steps in learning how to create a decent pudding.

Why Does Your Pudding Become Watery?

It is critical to note that adding any more liquid will result in the formation of a thin layer of watery film on top and at the bottom of your puddings.

This phenomena is based on chemical principles that state that when you combine one kind of liquid (in this example, milk) with another (eggs), you produce a third type that is a blend of the two.

In this example, it is an emulsion composed of tiny droplets suspended in liquid.

It is critical to understand that even though your puddings seem thick and creamy, they will have a watery layer at the bottom.

This is in addition to the layer that will be on top of your puddings, and you can only remove it by boiling your puddings thoroughly or placing them in soup bowls before serving if they are not fully cooked.

How Do You Thicken a Pudding?

After learning about the most typical pudding faults, it’s time to learn how to thicken the pudding.

There are two techniques to thicken your puddings.

You may thicken pudding by thickening the liquid you use or by adding anything that is formed of starch.

When it comes to thickeners, you have a terrific choice in the shape of cornstarch, which can be readily added to any pudding, from chocolate cake to cream pudding.

1 Use Cornstarch

The easiest technique to make a thick cornstarch pudding is to dissolve cornstarch in cold milk before adding any other ingredients.

You should avoid combining liquid and powder since this might result in lumps that are difficult to remove afterwards.

It is critical to use the correct quantity of cornstarch required to thicken your pudding since using too much may cause the liquid in your puddings to separate from the smooth and creamy consistency you want.

It may also result in a jelly or gum-like texture, which is not at all pleasant.

2 Cornflour-Free Thickening Pudding

The second thing you should know is that you can thicken pudding without adding cornflour.

It’s a fantastic practice if you want your puddings to be completely natural, but bear in mind that cow’s milk is not inherently thick and will need extra support from other components to properly gel.

To thicken puddings without adding cornflour, combine eggs and sugar with milk.

When combined with additional components, this combination will harden into a rigid product that will not curdle.

The bad news is that this approach requires rigorous cooking so that the egg is fully cooked before adding any additional ingredients to your puddings.

As you can see, learning how to create a nice pudding is all about knowing the proper quantities and which components to mix in order for your pudding recipe to turn out precisely how you want it to.

It also requires some skill since certain faults may be undetectable even when made but still have an impact on the final output of your puddings.

3 Making Use of Arrowroot Powder

If you wish to avoid using cornflour, arrowroot powder is a wonderful substitute.

It is created from arrowroot, a starchy tuberous rhizome or subterranean stem prized for its thickening abilities and used in a variety of dishes, including custards, puddings, cream, sauces, and gravies.

Simply speaking, arrowroot powder is created by grinding dried tuberous rhizomes and combining them with cooking soda and water to create a starch slurry.

It is mostly used to make puddings since it retains its consistency even when heated, while most other starches lose theirs as they cook.

To thicken pudding using arrowroot powder, first dissolve it in water or another liquid before adding it to your recipes.

It’s worth noting that arrowroot powder is more costly than cornstarch, but it’s also a superior thickening agent, which is why it’s favored for producing a thicker pudding.

4 Application of Gelatin

If you want your puddings to be thicker, gelatin is an excellent option.

It is a form of collagen derived from animal sources such as cow, fish, or pig bones, and it is utilized in a range of recipes due to its versatility in the kitchen.

Gelatin, for example, may be used to thicken puddings by creating a squeaky, jiggly texture known as sabayon or mousse.


To summarize, pudding is a delicious treat prepared from milk that often includes eggs, sugar, gelatin, or another thickening agent.

As you can see, there are various strategies for making your puddings thicker, so if you’re having difficulties, try all of the methods described above and see which one offers you the greatest results for your puddings.


How do you thicken pudding quickly?

When it comes to thickeners, you have a terrific choice in the shape of cornstarch, which can be readily added to any pudding, from chocolate cake to cream pudding. The easiest technique to make a thick cornstarch pudding is to dissolve cornstarch in cold milk before adding any other ingredients.

What ingredient makes pudding thick?

It is usually cooked with milk or cream, however there are nondairy puddings created using plant-based “milk.” Both pudding and custard may include eggs and milk, however pudding is often thickened with a starch, and custard is thickened by the eggs.

Why is my pudding not thickening?

The key approach to thicken pudding without adding extra thickeners is to be mindful of how much you are mixing it up. If you mix it too quickly, it will become too watery. If you mix it too little, the components will not blend properly.

What can I use to thicken pudding instead of cornstarch?

Replace one tablespoon of cornstarch with two teaspoons of tapioca starch. For cornstarch, use arrowroot or potato starch. Use arrowroot sparingly and avoid using it to thicken a cream or milk-based sauce since arrowroot coupled with milk may be sticky.

How do you make pudding thick liquid?

Suggestions for thickening fluids
To thicken 100 mL of liquids to a pudding-like consistency, use two scoops of “Thick and Easy®” powder.
Add the powder gradually, working quickly with a fork or small hand whisk.
Fluids containing thickening powder will thicken after standing.

How long does it take pudding to firm up?

Place the pudding in a bowl and refrigerate for 5 minutes. The pudding may seem thin at first, but it will thicken as it cools. After the 5 minutes are up, carefully insert a spoon into the pudding. If the pudding hasn’t set, keep it in the fridge for a little longer.

What is a healthy thickener for pudding?

Combine an alternate starch-based thickener, such as arrowroot powder, tapioca powder, or rice starch, with the sugar specified in your pudding recipe. In terms of thickening strength, these alternative starches are similar to cornstarch and twice as strong as wheat flour, so measure accordingly.

What can I add to pudding to make it better?

Add chopped nuts, chocolate chips, or baking spices like cinnamon or freshly grated nutmeg to taste. Don’t be shocked if they return for seconds! You may also garnish with sprinkles. They make things more enjoyable!

What thickens Jello pudding?

A Model for Quick Pudding Thickening

Some are used for anti-caking and other properties. The pudding is thickened by one ingredient. Tetrasodium pyrophosphate is the chemical name (TSPP).

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *