How Can I Make Baked Beans Thicker? A Step-by-Step Guide to Outstanding Baked Beans

Rate this post

Baked beans are pretty much a summer camp staple.

They taste much better when cooked in a wood-fired bean hole, but as most Yurpers don’t have access to one and may not want (or be able to construct) their own, cooking them in an oven or on an outside grill is more practical.

The issue with baked beans is that they are often very watery.

Since baked beans are intended to be a side dish for meat, they must have the consistency of a sauce.

Most people drown their beans in ketchup or mustard, but this just serves to disguise the issue.

Consistency is just as vital as taste. It’s not healthy to eat watery baked beans that taste like rice.

You must make certain that your beans are thick and ripe. You don’t have to be a scientist to get that lovely thick consistency.

These easy tips will get you there. This post will demonstrate how to thicken baked beans for the ideal side dish.

Why Should You Thicken Baked Beans?

When baked beans are done correctly, they are delicious.

They go well with a number of dishes, including sandwiches and burgers. They complement meats such as bacon.

Baked beans may also be eaten on their own, particularly if you season them with other ingredients.

One of the issues that people tend to have is getting baked beans to be thick enough or to have a texture that they like.

You can thin them down and make them watery, but they won’t taste as wonderful.

You may also make them overly thick, which can harden the exterior of your bean while leaving the majority of it undercooked on the inside.

So, how do you get them just right?

The first step is to make certain that the beans are sufficiently mushy.

No amount of cooking time will thicken them if they are too firm.

If they’re undercooked and still rough on the inside, they won’t cook as evenly.

This step must be completed correctly. There’s no excuse not to thicken your baked beans.

It may be done in a variety of ways, with some approaches performing better than others depending on the sort of consistency desired.

How Can I Make Baked Beans Thicker?

It might be difficult to thicken baked beans.

It’s easy to overdo it or underdo it, so here’s how to obtain that rich consistency you desire without making your meal too dry or watery.

If you’ve ever struggled to thicken cooked beans, this is a wonderful place to start.

1 Cooking with less water

The first advice is to use less water while preparing baked beans for the first time.

If all of the components in a dish are canned, the ratio should be around 1 cup of water to three cups of beans, or 4 cups.

In any case, it is better for you if you have to add extra water rather than using too much from the start.

It is preferable to concentrate on ensuring that the beans are well cooked rather than adding extra liquid to them.

You may easily add liquid later if necessary without having to worry about sloppy cooked beans (which will taste anything but delicious).

Pour in a tiny quantity of liquid and continue to add more if the sauce is still too thick.

It is simpler to add the excess liquid than to attempt to push it out afterwards.

The less moisture in the baked beans, the less likely they will burn on the bottom of the pan, changing color or becoming rough and chewy.

Consuming beans with too much water will make them difficult to digest, therefore you will not profit from them.

2 Bring the beans to a boil.

If the baked beans are too thin, you may return them to the oven for seven minutes at 430F.

This will decrease the liquid and thicken the sauce.

If using a stove, cook the beans on low and cover the pot. It should be stirred every now and again.

Let to cook until it acquires a rich, creamy consistency.

If you add spices or seasonings after the sauce has been reduced, the beans will burn.

3 Make use of cornmeal

Cornmeal thickens baked beans and gives them a deeper texture.

It’s an excellent thickening if you just use it for one dish since it won’t last more than three days in the fridge.

If you mistakenly add too much liquid to your beans, this is a quick cure.

Consider adding a little cornmeal to the saucepan the next time you prepare them.

It will help you get the desired thick consistency without overdoing it or making the meal taste gritty.

4 Grind the Beans

Beans’ waxy core makes them an excellent option for preparing a sauce or thickening a meal.

Mashing the beans reduces their size and helps to thicken the sauce in which they are cooked.

A lot of heat is required to make mashed beans hold together; otherwise, the mash will not thicken.

It will also contribute to the meal having a chewier texture, which some people enjoy.

If you want a smooth consistency in your baked beans, crush them first and then whisk them into the sauce.

Return the beans to the pot after they have been mashed.

Stir everything together well, then set aside for 30 minutes before adding any spices or seasonings.

This will make your dish’s texture less watery or grainy.

5 Make use of cornstarch

Cornstarch is an excellent thickening for baked beans since it does not have the gritty flavor that cornmeal does.

It’s also reasonably priced and easily accessible at any grocery shop.

The big advantage of using cornstarch as a thickening is that it can be made ahead of time and refrigerated until needed.

To thicken your beans using cornstarch, follow these steps:

  1. Begin by blending a tiny amount of water and cornstarch in a small dish.
  2. When adding the clumps to the pot, make sure they are completely broken up.
  3. Heat this mixture in a saucepan over medium-high heat.
  4. Stir constantly until the mixture is thickened and smooth.

6 Apply a Thickening Agent

Beans may be flavored and thickened using seasonings.

Condiments like as honey, brown sugar, and molasses may be used to thicken the sauce.

These are also nice choices if your beans are too thick.

You may add soy sauce to make it more flavorful.

Combine this with the heated beans to add another layer of flavor.

When the condiment heats and interacts with the other ingredients, it will thicken the bean.

These ingredients will assist shorten the cooking time of the soup by adding flavor and thickening the sauce.

7 Make use of butter and flour

If cornstarch is unavailable, beans may be thickened using a variety of alternative thickening agents.

In lieu of cornstarch, you may use butter and flour, or a mixture of the two.

To thicken your beans, do the following:

  1. Combine equal parts butter and flour.
  2. When the pot is still on low heat, add this combination.
  3. Continue to whisk until the butter and flour mixture has melted.


Some may argue that bean boiling is not a precise science.

Yet, with a little imagination and practice, you may learn how to create the most flavorful and tasty beans every time.

Patience and practice will help you figure out what tastes best for your household.

You only need to practice often to improve your skills.

You’ll be able to produce the ideal bean dish for your family with a little time and expertise.


How do you make bean liquid thicker?

Dissolve a teaspoon or two of cornstarch or all-purpose flour in a tiny quantity of cold water in a separate dish. Pour the slurry into the simmering soup. The soup should thicken as it sits. Add extra cornstarch or flour as required to get the appropriate consistency.

Do homemade baked beans thicken as they cool?

The longer the beans are cooked, the thicker they will get. Keep in mind that they will thicken as they cool. Remove from oven, mix, and set aside for 15-20 minutes before serving.

What flour to thicken baked beans?

4 – Flour and butter are other options.

Flour and butter can assist you in thickening baked beans wonderfully. To be honest, most thickening agents used in circumstances like these will be starch-based. Flour meets the bill and, in most cases, works just as well as cornstarch.

Will brown sugar thicken baked beans?

Condiments like as honey, brown sugar, and molasses may be used to thicken the sauce. These are also nice choices if your beans are too thick.

How do you elevate baked beans?

How to Make Canned Baked Beans Better
This is maple syrup.
Mustard with a kick.
Sausage made from beef.
Vinegar of cider.
Sep 1, 2017

How do you remove liquid from beans?

How to Drain and Rinse Canned Beans
Use a can opener to open your canned beans. Opening the can may result in sharp edges.
Place the open can of beans in a strainer over a sink and let the extra liquid to drain entirely.
Rinse well with cold water until the liquid is clear.
Sep 28, 2022

How do you make baked beans less dry?

If the beans are too dry, add a splash of hot water—or leftover bean-cooking water, if you have any—until they’re just saucy enough.

Does baking soda thicken beans?

Since baking powder commonly includes cornstarch, it may be used to thicken sauces. Since baking soda lacks cornstarch, it cannot be used as a thickening. Cornstarch is what holds the wet components together, making the mixture smoother and thicker.

What happens if you overcook baked beans?

Your beans have been overcooked.

Beans that are excessively soft and mushy are signs that they have been overdone. Tender beans are great, but if they lack firmness and do not hold their form, they have most likely been cooked for too long. Overcooked beans will also lose flavor, leaving a bland taste.

How do you thicken gravy for beans?

For each cup of medium-thick sauce, combine one tablespoon cornstarch with one tablespoon cold water (a cornstarch slurry). Mix the cornstarch and water completely before adding it to your sauce. Cook, stirring constantly, over medium heat until thickened and bubbling.

Recommended Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *