Best Broiler Pan Reviews 2022 – Top 5 Picks

5/5 - (1 vote)

Disclosure: Our editors independently review and test the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We receive a small commission from purchases made via some links on this website. We do not accept free products from manufacturers, and we never allow ourselves to be influenced by how much money we could make off a certain product.

Having a broiler pan in your kitchen is one of the most important pieces of cooking equipment you can have if you want to reduce the amount of physical labor you do in the kitchen while still preparing a dish that is comforting for your loved ones.

Make your culinary endeavor as simple and uncomplicated as possible by using your most reliable kitchen partner, the oven or broiler pans, no matter whether you want to bake, grill, or broil your food.

When a food item such as fish, meat, or even vegetables is placed inside of the cooking oven, a broiler pan is designed specifically to meet the demands of preserving the nutrients and all other key minerals of the food item in question. This can be a challenge.

A peculiar hollow cutout design is used in the construction of the pan to ensure that it retains the maximum amount of heat that is generated by the oven. As a result, the food is able to cook more quickly.

It is currently impossible to choose the best broiler pan because the market is flooded with an infinite number of options for purchasing a broiler pan.

As a result, we will now discuss the best 5 broiler pans that are now available for purchase.

5 Best Broiler Pan Reviews 2022

1 – Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan

If you are seeking for a broiler pan that can manage your daily broiling demands with maximum ease, the Whirlpool 4396923 may be the appropriate cooking buddy for you to have in your kitchen.

The pan comes with a separate roasting rack as well as a metal grid in addition to the standard broiler pan itself. This enables you to broil almost any type of food item (vegetables, meat, poultry, etc.) on your oven’s broiler with a minimum of effort and in a manner that is uncomplicated and easy to understand.

Also, let’s not forget the huge amount of money it saves you on your pocket expenditures as well as other things.

The inside of the broiler pan is made of stainless steel, and it is finished with porcelain. This construction not only guarantees that the heat-absorption mechanism is operating at its highest possible level, but it also supports the pan’s highest possible degree of durability.

Because the pan has a non-stick coating, the surface may be readily cleaned with your hand without using any additional cleaning products.

In addition to this, the pan features a horizontal venting design, which ensures that any oil and other mineral residues left over from the meal will properly drain to the bottom of the pan.

In addition, the surface of the pan is much broader compared to the majority of its contemporaries, making it possible to put many things all at once.

In general, the Whirlpool 4396923 Broiler Pan is one of the most effective and long-lasting broiler pans that can currently be purchased.


  • The construction is of an exceptionally sturdy grade.
  • Offers improved control over the dispersion of heat
  • Adaptable to a wide variety of cooking appliances
  • Excellent return on investment


  • Cannot withstand very high temperatures.
  • The size of the broiler might often be unimpressive.
Check Latest Price

2 – General Electric WB48X10056 Large Broiler Pan

In a nutshell, the WB48X10056 broiler pan is intended to function as a genuine replacement component for a wide variety of ovens manufactured by General Electric.

Nevertheless, it is possible to use it successfully for almost any other kind of ovens as well, which makes it one of the hottest (pun intended) options that could be taken into consideration.

The WB48X10056 broiler pan, just like the majority of other broiler pans on the market, is perfect for preparing any kind of food, from vegetables to poultry products and everything in between.

In addition to that, it can also be utilized to its full potential as an efficient springform pan for the purpose of catering to your baking requirements.

The surface of the pan features a prominent vented design, which not only makes the process of draining excess fat from the meat very simple but also ensures that the food is cooked perfectly evenly on all sides.

The steel used to make the pan is of an industrial grade, which means that it will maintain its high level of durability even when subjected to temperatures that are extremely high.

The coating on the pan is made of a non-stick porcelain that makes it very easy to remove any food residue that may have been left behind.

This broiler pan also features a large cooking surface that is capable of supporting sufficient quantities of food items to meet the needs of any family-sized meal.


  • It is not difficult to clean.
  • The configuration of the vent is efficient in removing fats from the food.
  • Ample space for use as a cooking surface
  • Extremely durable


  • During handling, you could have some difficulty due to the rough edges of the vents.
  • The coating may be readily peeled off.
Check Latest Price

3 – Range Kleen BP106X 2 PC Porcelain Broil and Bake Pan

The vast majority of conventional broiler pans have a significant drawback that is shared by all of them, and that is that they have a limited heat capacity.

On the other hand, this is precisely the kind of environment in which the Range Kleen broiler pan thrives.

If you are looking for a pan that can cook your food in the shortest amount of time possible, the BP106X is an excellent choice that you should give serious consideration to making.

Because it can withstand temperatures up to the maximum effective cooking temperature of 1,025 degrees Fahrenheit, the Range Kleen broiler pan is also an excellent choice for evenly distributing heat throughout the cooking process.

Because it is constructed out of a heavy-duty steel material, the pan is able to withstand the extremely high temperature settings that are used.

The non-stick porcelain coating not only prevents food from sticking to the pan, but also eliminates the risk of stains being left behind by foods.

The intelligent blunt grate design on the surface also makes it easier to handle as well as the slanted grate design on the grilling surface, which is also sufficient for draining out the fats efficiently.


  • It is available as part of a package that consists of two separate items.
  • It can tolerate a great deal of heat without being damaged.
  • Extremely sturdy and long-lasting in its quality
  • The system is both small and lightweight.


  • Because of the shape of the deep grate, it is sometimes difficult to clean.
  • Less room in the kitchen
Check Latest Price


Finding the best broiling pan for your needs can be a challenging task, particularly if you do not have the resources necessary to conduct the research necessary to determine which products are designed to be able to fulfill your requirements in the best possible way.

The list that was just presented contains several of the most effective broiling pans that can fulfill virtually any kind of fundamental cooking requirement, from making a straightforward frittata to baking cookies and cakes.

However, out of the three cooking pans, the Whirlpool 4396923 is the most compelling option to consider if you are looking for an all-rounder broiling pan that not only offers the best value for the money but also ensures the highest possible efficiency when broiling food.


What pans are safe for the broiler?

If your nonstick cookware or bakeware does not expressly say “broiler safe” or “safe up to 550°F,” your best bet is to choose all-metal pans such as stainless steel or seasoned cast iron. If your cookware or bakeware does say “broiler safe” or “safe up to 550°F,” it is safe to use.

What is the difference between a roasting pan and a broiler pan?

A method of cooking that utilizes the entire oven, including the top, bottom, and even the rear of the device, is referred to as “all-over cooking.” Baking and roasting both utilize all-over heat, but roasting does so at significantly higher temperatures. The top of food can be browned or crisped using the broiling technique, which employs top-down heat at high and even extremely high temperatures.

Can broiler pan go in dishwasher?

Pour grease into a disposable can. After it has cooled down, wash the pan using hot water and a gentle cleanser. Drain and pat dry. Do not put any racks or pans that are coated with porcelain in the dishwasher.

What is the best broiler pan?

Best Broiler Pan Overall

  • Broiler Pan by Williams Sonoma with Goldtouch Finish.
  • Bake, broil, and grill food in this Granite Ware pan.
  • Range Kleen Broiler Pans.
  • Norpro NonStick Broil/Roast Pan is the pan in question.
  • Genuine porcelain broiler pan manufactured by Whirlpool.
  • Farberware’s steel roaster has a nonstick coating and a flat rack.

What brand of pans are best?

Happy cooking!

  • All-Clad is the best heavy-duty option. All Clad. …
  • Most Desired: Le Creuset. Le Creuset. …
  • Caraway is the most chemical-free option. Caraway. …
  • Best Brand Values: T-fal. T-fal
  • Most Versatile: Ninja. Ninja. …
  • Calphalon is the most dependable brand. The name Calphalon…
  • Best Nonstick: Circulon. Circulon. …
  • Best Budget: Gotham Steel. Gotham Steel. Get it?

Recommended Articles